Natural Resources

Fall 2011 Natural Resources Law Class at UB

Tapping into the Truth September 29, 2011

Filed under: Uncategorized — inagais @ 5:42 pm

Growing up I was incredibly lucky to have live on a hill overlooking Seneca Lake in the Fingerlakes. In fact, anyone growing up in that region was lucky. We had pristine water to boat on, creeks to swim in, wetlands to survey, and (most of us) even had our own wells to get drinking water from. It is because of this that most people in the Finger Lakes appreciate and trust water directly from a natural source. In fact, the only bottled water my parents ever bought was seltzer for special occasions! Some, however, aren’t so lucky to have grown up around the Finger Lakes. For those unlucky masses,however, God created bottled water on the tenth day and it was good.

The interesting thing about the “bottled v. tap” water debate is that, in my experience, I’ve found that your parents treatment of tap water seems to play a large role in what side people place themselves on. I had parents who always placed tap water in front of us without any worry that it would cause us cancer or gangrene. However, if your parents had you drinking from a filter all the time, and you only saw tap water being used for the toilet, sink, or shower, it wouldn’t be surprising if you began to form the opinion that tap water is only worthy of washing away filth, but not good for consumption.

Although it is true that almost one billion people worldwide lack access to safe water (, the United States is near the bottom of the list of those countries affected. Furthermore, many studies show that city tap water is actually healthy. So, if not simply for the fact that our parents told us to drink bottled water, where did this bottled water obsession come from?

Annie Leonard, the author of The Story of Stuff, has one theory that is pretty darn interesting. She believes that it was “manufactured demand,” facilitated by the companies behind that sell bottled water. The demand is manufactured by basically scaring people into believing their tap water is dangerous through very well-funded advertising campaigns. While I’d recommend reading her book… or perhaps I could write more details here… I realize that none of us have the time for that now. So, YOU TUBE to the rescue! Below is a link to a wonderful video Annie Leonard created, outlining her bottled water theory. It is worth a look!



4 Responses to “Tapping into the Truth”

  1. letecia Says:

    It is difficult to accept the idea that most of us will wash our dishes, our hair, our faces, our bodies, and brush our teeth with tap, but we won’t drink it.

    I returned to tap and love saving time and money!

  2. neasasen Says:

    I also primarily drink tap water, because I am cheap and hate the thought of all those plastic water bottles in the garbage. It just seems so wasteful. However, recently road construction crews broke the water main and the water was under a boil advisory for days, so I had to give in and purchase water. I mean who has the time to boil, cool, refridgerate and drink when they are thristy now? I dont know if I was more annoyed with the safety of the water or just thankful we have the option to purchase water so widely now. So while I may primarily drink tap water, I still like the convenience of bottled water, particularly for emergencies.

    Plus I guess tap water is fine provided they do alert the public when water quality is unsafe to drink.

  3. leebender Says:

    While there are places that I freely drink tap water, Buffalo isn’t one of those places. It always tastes ultra-chlorinated or like algae to me. Plus, I have a habit of living in older buildings that probably have old lead pipes, and believe it or not, there are plenty of toxins in tapwater (mounting prescription drug issues come to mind).

    However, I think bottled water is one of the most environmentally tragic things to hit our market. Instead, I bought a 10-stage water filter that I’ll only have to replace the filter on every couple of years. It’s much higher quality than say a Brita or equivalent, but I also am not wasting plastic or getting poisoned so much…

  4. leebender Says:

    And Adam, I completely agree about Finger Lakes water. Cayuga’s tastes amazing from the source. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s